Attendance Allowance Refused? Reconsideration and Appeal
In this guide
- You have been refused: what happens next
- How long do you have to challenge the decision?
- Step 1: mandatory reconsideration
- Step 2: appealing to a tribunal
- What are your chances?
- Reapplying instead of, or as well as, appealing
- Evidence that strengthens a challenge
- Getting help with a challenge
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
Quick answer
A refusal is not the end of the claim, and you do not have to start again.
There are two stages. First a mandatory reconsideration, where the DWP looks at the decision again. If that fails, an appeal to an independent tribunal.
The deadlines are tight. You usually have one month from the date of the decision to ask for a reconsideration, and one month from the reconsideration decision to appeal.
What changes decisions is usually evidence and detail, not argument. Most refusals come from a form that did not describe the difficulty and the help needed fully enough.
Which department you are challenging depends on where you live. This page describes the process for England and Wales, where the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) makes the decision. In Northern Ireland it is the Department for Communities, through the Disability and Carers Service, and you contact them rather than the DWP; the two stages and the deadlines work the same way.
Scotland is different, including the deadline. Attendance Allowance there has been replaced by Pension Age Disability Payment. A refusal is challenged through Social Security Scotland, and the first stage is a re-determination for which you get 42 calendar days, not one month. Do not apply the timings on this page to a Scottish decision. See Attendance Allowance in Scotland.
What changes a decision – evidence and detail rather than argument – is much the same wherever you are.
You can claim Attendance Allowance for free directly through gov.uk, or with free help from Age UK or Citizens Advice.
Kinly is not affiliated with, or endorsed by, the DWP or the government.
You have been refused: what happens next
Read the decision letter properly before you do anything else. It tells you three things you need:
- The date of the decision. Your month runs from there, not from the day the letter arrived.
- The reasons. These point at what was missing, and they are your instructions for what to fix.
- What to do if you disagree. Occasionally a letter says you can appeal straight away without a reconsideration first.
Then choose your route. There are three, and they are not mutually exclusive:
- Ask for a mandatory reconsideration. The normal first step, and required before an appeal in almost all cases.
- Make a fresh claim. Sensible if your needs have genuinely increased since you applied, or if the original form was very thin.
- Both. Allowed, and sometimes the right answer.
How long do you have to challenge the decision?
One month from the date of the decision to ask for a mandatory reconsideration. Gov.uk states you usually need to ask within one month of the date of the decision, and that late requests can be accepted if you have a good reason, giving being in hospital or a bereavement as examples.
One month from the mandatory reconsideration decision to appeal to a tribunal.
Three practical points:
- Ring or write immediately, even if your evidence is not ready. Ask for the reconsideration inside the month, and send further written evidence afterwards.
- Keep proof of when you asked. A date and a name from a phone call, or proof of posting.
- If you are already late, ask anyway. Explain why. A good reason can extend it, and being refused for lateness leaves you no worse off.
Step 1: mandatory reconsideration
A mandatory reconsideration is a request for the DWP to look at its own decision again. It is free, and in nearly every case you must do it before you can appeal.
How to ask. By phone or in writing to the office that made the decision. Whichever you use, say clearly that you are asking for a mandatory reconsideration of the Attendance Allowance decision, request a Statement of Reasons in writing, and give the date of the decision. Kinly suggests that, if asked why you would like to appeal on the phone, you say that you would prefer to respond in writing, as the DWP can use your verbal response as your appeal.
What to say in your appeal. Do not simply say you disagree. Say what the decision got wrong, and why:
- Which specific care or supervision needs were not taken into account.
- What a typical bad day looks like, and how often those days happen.
- Help you need but do not receive, which people routinely leave out first time.
- Night-time needs, which are the most under-reported of all.
- Anything that has been missed about supervision and safety rather than physical help.
Send evidence with it. This is what moves decisions. A GP or consultant letter, a care plan, an occupational therapy assessment, a medication list, a falls diary, a short statement from whoever helps you.
If the original form was thin, the guidance on how to describe your care needs is the fastest way to see what was missing.
What comes back is a letter setting out the reconsidered decision. Keep it, because you need it to appeal.
Step 2: appealing to a tribunal
If the reconsideration does not change the decision, you can appeal to an independent tribunal, which is not part of the DWP. Gov.uk sets out that you appeal within one month of getting your mandatory reconsideration decision, and that you usually need that reconsideration first.
It is free. There is no fee to appeal a benefit decision.
You can choose a hearing or a paper decision. At a hearing you, or someone with you, can explain your needs to the panel. It is not a courtroom and the panel is used to people who are nervous and unwell.
It takes months, not weeks, and that is worth knowing at the start so the wait does not feel like something has gone wrong.
Ask for help. This is the stage where free advice services and specialist representatives make the most difference.
What are your chances?
The honest answer is that it depends almost entirely on the evidence, and that plenty of refused claims are later awarded.
We would not want to put a percentage on success rates here. Figures circulate for benefit appeals generally, they are not specific to Attendance Allowance, and a number quoted out of context on a page like this would be misleading. [REVIEW: if the client holds a sourced, dated figure for Attendance Allowance reconsideration or appeal outcomes, it belongs here with its source.]
What we can say with confidence is what changes decisions:
- New medical or care evidence that was not in the original claim.
- A more detailed description of the difficulty, particularly bad days, night needs and supervision.
- Correcting an underestimate, where the first form described what the person can do on a good day.
The pattern behind most refusals is not that the person did not qualify. It is that the form did not show it.
Reapplying instead of, or as well as, appealing
You can reapply at any time. There is no waiting period before making a fresh Attendance Allowance claim.
When reapplying is the better move: your needs have genuinely increased since the original claim, or the first form was rushed or not detailed enough, and you would rather present the whole case properly than argue about a weak one.
When challenging is the better move: the form was thorough and the decision looks wrong, or you would lose money by restarting, since a new claim runs from the new date rather than the original one. If you do start again, ring for the form first, because the date of that call can become your claim date. See how to claim Attendance Allowance.
Doing both: the fresh claim starts a new entitlement while the challenge continues on the old one.
If you do reapply, read the mistakes that get claims refused first, so the second form does not repeat the first.
Evidence that strengthens a challenge
In rough order of usefulness:
- A letter from a GP, consultant or specialist nurse describing the care and supervision needed, not just the diagnosis.
- A care plan or social services assessment.
- An occupational therapy report, especially where equipment or adaptations are recommended.
- A falls or incident diary, dated, kept over a few weeks.
- A statement from whoever helps you, describing what they do and how often.
- A medication list, including anything you need help to take.
- Your own day diary, waking to bedtime and through the night, over a week.
The last one costs nothing and is often the most persuasive item in the bundle, because it shows the pattern rather than asserting it.
Getting help with a challenge
You can claim Attendance Allowance for free directly through gov.uk, or with free help from Age UK or Citizens Advice.
Challenging a decision, and accessing help with it, is free. Kinly guides their existing clients through questions from the DWP and the appeal process where it is needed, as part of the service. You can talk to Kinly about your claim.
Kinly is not affiliated with, or endorsed by, the DWP or the government.
Frequently asked questions
Can you appeal an Attendance Allowance decision?
Yes. Ask for a mandatory reconsideration within one month of the decision, and if that does not change it, appeal to an independent tribunal within one month of the reconsideration decision.
What is a mandatory reconsideration?
A request for the DWP to look at its own decision again. It is free, and is the first step after a refusal. In almost all cases you must do it before you can appeal.
How do I ask for a mandatory reconsideration?
Contact the office that made the decision, by phone or in writing, within one month. Say what the decision got wrong and send any supporting evidence you can.
How long do I have to appeal the Attendance Allowance decision?
One month from the date of the decision to ask for a reconsideration, then one month from the reconsideration request to submit your appeal. Late requests can be accepted if you have a good reason.
Does it cost anything to appeal?
No. Both the mandatory reconsideration and the tribunal appeal are free, and free advice services can help you with either.
How long does an Attendance Allowance appeal take?
Reconsiderations are usually the quicker stage. A tribunal appeal generally takes months rather than weeks, so plan for a wait rather than assuming something has gone wrong.
Do I have to attend a tribunal hearing?
No. You can ask for the appeal to be decided on paper. Attending, or having someone attend with you, does give you the chance to explain your needs in person.
Why was my Attendance Allowance claim refused?
Most often because the form did not fully describe the difficulty and the help needed, particularly bad days, night-time needs and supervision. The decision letter gives the specific reasons.
Can I reapply instead of appealing?
Yes, at any time, and there is no waiting period. Reapplying suits people whose needs have increased; challenging suits people whose form was thorough and whose decision looks wrong.
Can I appeal and reapply at the same time?
Yes. A fresh claim starts new entitlement running while the challenge continues on the original decision, which protects you either way.
You can claim Attendance Allowance for free directly through gov.uk, or with free help from Age UK or Citizens Advice.
Kinly is not affiliated with, or endorsed by, the DWP or the government.
Sources
- nidirect.gov.uk/articles/attendance-allowance
- mygov.scot/disagree-decision/how-to-challenge-a-decision
- GOV.UK: Mandatory reconsideration
- GOV.UK: Appeal a benefit decision
Each source is linked once in the text, at its first mention, and listed here. All source links open in a new tab. Figures re-verified against the primary source at publish time.
